(#56 in the family of Nature motifs, variations on the Primal Nature Motif #1 and Rhine Motifs #2 and #3, which include #12)
[[#57ab]] “Wotan's Grand Idea” of redemption from Alberich’s curse on his Ring
Commonly known as the “Sword Motif” - Wotan’s grand idea of redemption from Alberich’s curse on his Ring is to produce a race of heroes who can redeem Valhalla’s gods (religious faith) from Alberich’s threat to make all men as conscious as he is of the objective truth, by restoring lost innocence. These Waelsung heroes are to inherit a sword made by Wotan, whose motif #57 incorporates the Primal Nature Motif #1, and therefore represents the innocent time before the Fall.
(#57a based on the octave drop when Erda, during her prophecy of the gods' doom, said that (#53) All things that are, (#Octave Drop) end!; #57b based on #1; related to other Nature arpeggios like #12 and #56; related through #1 to #53 and #54, and through #53's last three notes to the set of heroic motifs which include #71, #77, #88, #92, #95, and perhaps #152)
[[#58ab]] Valhalla as religious man’s refuge from dread and dismay in the face of truth
Wotan’s Waelsung heroes are Siegmund, Wagner’s idea of a moral hero, and Siegmund’s son Siegfried, Wagner’s metaphor for an artist-hero (such as Wagner himself). Wotan hopes that these heroes, wielding his sword (later christened by Siegmund: Nothung), will preserve Valhalla, man’s heritage of religious illusion, from the truth.
(#58a’s motival links, if any, not yet ascertained; #58b basis of #79)
[[#59abc]] The Rhinedaughters’ first lament for the lost Rhinegold
Nature's lament for the innocence that has been lost through man's natural acquisition of the power of conscious human thought, a basis for man's longing to restore lost innocence in musical feeling.
(#59a a variant of #15; #59bc’s motival links, if any, not yet ascertained; is #59bc a #4 or #16 variant in the minor?)